Porcupine Tree

With 10 studio albums, countless live albums, compilations and EPs, and near endless outtakes, the Porcupine Tree discography can be quite daunting for a new fan. So, I figured I would break it down and offer my suggestions for those eager to explore the vast catalogue!

What I have done is chosen one song from each of the 10 studio albums that I feel best encapsulates the respective album’s sound in an accessible way. The reaction to each song will determine what album to start with. After that, each album will have its own guide with it as the starting point (as everybody has different tastes and will start somewhere different). For a really short version of the guide, scroll all the way to the bottom of the page. However, while this is also helpful, I highly recommend you stick with the long guide as it will guide you through the entire Porcupine Tree discography in extensive detail.

While the best way to listen to Porcupine Tree is with entire albums, as intended by Steven Wilson, songs are still meant to stand on their own and will serve as the best way to figure out what you do or don’t like about the band’s music (to determine how to proceed).

The primer list of songs is as follows (I have mixed the songs to avoid a chronological list in case you have prior knowledge with or expectations regarding each album; this way there will be no bias):

“Trains”

“Even Less”

“Radioactive Toy”

“Shesmovedon”

“Fear of a Blank Planet”

  • Spotify
  • Google Play
  • Apple Music
  • Youtube

“Waiting (Phase One)”

“Always Never”

“Open Car”

“Stars Die”

“Remember Me Lover”

Starting Points

If your favourite track from the list was…

  • “Trains”, find #7
  • “Even Less”, find #5
  • “Radioactive Toy”, find #1
  • “Shesmovedon”, find #6
  • “Fear of a Blank Planet”, find #9
  • “Waiting (Phase One)”, find #4
  • “Always Never”, find #2
  • “Open Car”, find #8
  • “Stars Die”, find #3
  • “Remember Me Lover”, find #10

Guides

Depending on your song of choice, you will be directed to its respective album. After listening to the album, you will choose your next album (based on the songs you liked). Under each album, I list what material is reminiscent of material on other albums. The process continues until you have listened to all 10 albums (continue jumping around by following links between albums that you haven’t checked out yet). If the album you’re on has no links to an album you haven’t listened to yet, just take your pick on where you should go next by looking at the original list of songs and what you liked. Essentially, this part of the guide will help you regarding the listening order of the albums. It’s like one of those “Choose Your Own Adventure” books!

#1: “On The Sunday of Life…”

Summary:

Release: June 1992

pic

A word of warning, this album (the debut) is quite difficult to get into, let alone for a newcomer. This album is a collection of experiments recorded by a young Steven Wilson in his bedroom in the late ’80s and early ’90s. While some of the material here is absolutely exceptional, it is the polar opposite of “easy to get”. Given your love for “Radioactive Toy”, you must be into the spacier aspects of Porcupine Tree so I believe it will be beneficial for you to jump into Up The Downstair (#2) or The Sky Moves Sideways (#3) (depending on your tastes) instead. For more electronic-based and psychedelic music, check out the former and for Floydian-inspired space rock check out the latter.

g

Continue reading only if you’ve listened to a handful of other albums first!

Links:

So, how did you like the album? I’m guessing it wasn’t what you expected! Alright, so here’s the list of where you should go next depending on what you dug from the album:

  • “Jupiter Island” & “The Nostalgia Factory” – Up The Downstair (#2)
  • “Radioactive Toy”, “Begonia Seduction Scene” & “It Will Rain For A Million Years” – The Sky Moves Sideways (#3)
  • “And The Swallows Dance Above The Sun” & “This Long Silence” – Signify (#4)
  • “Nine Cats” & “Footprints” – Lightbulb Sun (#6)

#2: “Up The Downstair”

Summary: The second Porcupine Tree album, Up The Downstair, sees Wilson experiment with acid house rhythms, psychedelic guitar and synth loops.

Release: May 1993

1993_Up_the_Downstair

If this was your first pick, you’re here because you dig the spacier aspects of Porcupine Tree’s music. Right on!

“Up The Downstair is a startling, electrifying journey. It pulsates with the sense of discovery. Here’s a band who are not only prepared to throw away rock’s rule book, but to set the thing on fire and dance among the flames.” – Melody Maker

Up The Downstair saw contributions from two future band members; bassist Colin Edwin on “Always Never” and keyboard maestro Richard Barbieri on the title track. The version you’ve likely heard is the 2004 reissue with Gavin Harrison’s (the drummer from 2002 onwards) drums (the original version of the album had programmed drums, similar to On The Sunday of Life…).

Links:

Now that you’ve listened to it, what songs on the album did you like the most?

  • “Synesthesia” & “Small Fish” – On The Sunday of Life… (#1)
  • “Always Never” – Lightbulb Sun (#6)
  • “Up The Downstair” & “Not Beautiful Anymore” – Signify (#4)
  • “Burning Sky” & “Fadeaway” – The Sky Moves Sideways (#3), Deadwing (#8)

#3: “The Sky Moves Sideways”

Summary: A grand space rock opus, The Sky Moves Sideways is a brilliant album awash with hypnotic guitar passages, dreamy vocals and intricate rhythm tracks.

Release: February 1995

1995_The_Sky_Moves_Sideways
The artwork created for The Sky Moves Sideways by Mike Bennion, Claudine Schafer and Daniel Ray Billington

If this was your first pick, you’re likely here because you’re interested in the Pink Floyd-ian and space rock elements of Porcupine Tree’s music.

“A momentous achievement in modern psych-rock.” – Rock ‘n’ Reel

The Sky Moves Sideways was the first Porcupine Tree album to feature contributions from all members of the band (with Chris Maitland rounding out the line-up on drums), although half of the music still remained a solo project for Wilson. In 2003, Gavin Harrison re-recorded the drums for the Wilson-only tracks “Dislocated Day” and “The Moon Touches Your Shoulder” (on which he had used drum machines).

Links:

Now that you’ve listened to it, what did you like the best?

  • “The Sky Moves Sideways”, “Prepare Yourself” & “Moonloop” – Signify (#4)
  • “Dislocated Day” – Signify (#4), In Absentia (#7), Deadwing (#8), Fear of a Blank Planet (#9), The Incident (#10)
  • “The Moon Touches Your Shoulder” & “Stars Die” – Stupid Dream (#5), Lightbulb Sun (#6)

#4: “Signify”

Summary: Caught between the band’s psychedelic roots and their song-oriented future, Signify is a dark, brooding album that stands out in the discography

Release: September 1996

YStK7V8
The artwork created for Signify by John Blackford

If this was your first pick, you’re likely here because you’re interested in the more textural, beat driven and darker aspects of Porcupine Tree’s music.

“The most accomplished work yet from this band. Subtly mesmerising and structurally flamboyant they continue to weave ambient almost rock-like music into shapeless feelings and fleeting glances of both the past before my existence and the future beyond it.” – Buzz Factory

Signify was the first album to feature the entire band throughout and have them involved in the creative process, with various songs written by all three other members.

Links:

Now that you’ve listened to it, what songs on the album did you like the most?

  • “Signify” & “Sever” – In Absentia (#7), Fear of a Blank Planet (#9)
  • “Sleep Of No Dreaming”, “Waiting (Phase One)” & “Every Home is Wired” – Stupid Dream (#5), Lightbulb Sun (#6), In Absentia (#7), The Incident (#10)
  • “Waiting (Phase Two), “Intermediate Jesus” & “”Light Mass Prayers”” – Up The Downstair (#2), The Sky Moves Sideways (#3)
  • “Dark Matter” – The Sky Moves Sideways (#3), In Absentia (#7), Deadwing (#8)

#5: “Stupid Dream”

Summary: Stupid Dream was the first album in the Porcupine Tree catalogue to feature a more song-oriented direction (although never losing the experimental edge from previous releases).

Release: March 1999

1999_Stupid_Dream
The artwork created for (the 2006 re-release of) Stupid Dream by Lasse Hoile

If this was your first pick, you’re likely here because you like the more song and rock-oriented material from Porcupine Tree! Solid choice.

“… some of the quartet’s biggest, blasting rock epic music yet, yet also shot through with the gentler, acoustic side that makes Porcupine Tree so intimate and lovely…  Wilson as a songwriter and singer both sounds recharged and more ambitious, while the group collectively pours it on. The loud passages feel truly sky-smashing, the calmer ones perfectly close, and the overall sense of build and drama–’A Smart Kid’ is a fine example–spot-on.” – AllMusic

At the time, Stupid Dream was a radical departure for Porcupine Tree. With soaring vocal melodies, slick and smart guitar playing and tight song arrangements, Stupid Dream was very different from the previous, more instrumentally complex material found on albums such as The Sky Moves Sideways and Up The Downstair.

Links:

Now that you’ve listened to it, what songs on the album did you like the most?

  • “Even Less”, “This Is No Rehearsal” & “A Smart Kid” – Signify (#4), In Absentia (#7), Deadwing (#8)
  • “Piano Lessons” – On The Sunday Of Life… (#1), Up The Downstair (#2), Lightbulb Sun (#6), The Incident (#10)
  • “Pure Narcotic”, “Slave Called Shiver” & “Baby Dream in Cellophane” – Lightbulb Sun (#6), In Absentia (#7), Deadwing (#8)
  • “Don’t Hate Me” & “Stranger By The Minute” – Lightbulb Sun (#6), Deadwing (#8), The Incident (#10)
  • “Tinto Brass” – Up The Downstair (#2), Signify (#4)
  • “Stop Swimming” – Lightbulb Sun (#6), In Absentia (#7), The Incident (#10)

#6: “Lightbulb Sun”

Summary: The continuation of Steven Wilson’s obsession with Brian Wilson-esque song craft found on Stupid Dream but with more instrumental experimentation and organic production.

Release: May 2000

Untitled design (12)
The artwork created for Lightbulb Sun by John Foxx

If this was your first choice, you’re likely here because you’re into the “warmer”, acoustic-based tracks from the band. You’ll find plenty of Beatles-esque vocal harmonies here!

“… their greatest strength: the ability to keep oddball, experimental music firmly anchored with two feet on the ground, so that not only the artistic musos can appreciate the vacuity, gloom and absurdity of the music, but also that the common man, oblivious to 16-minute meanderings and jagged odd-time riffs, can appreciate the music for its calm, soothing poppy nature; almost never have the realms of progressive, virtuosic music and the commonality of modern pop been so closely entwined. It is one of the great talents of Wilson that he can effectively combine the two without either sounding watered down or losing focus.” – Sputnik Music

Lightbulb Sun continues the musical style established with Stupid Dream although with the addition of more stripped down, organic production and experimental aspects that the band had moved away from on Stupid Dream.

Links:

Now that you’ve listened to it, what songs on the album did you like the most?

  • “Lightbulb Sun” & “How is Your Life Today?” – The Incident (#10)
  • “The Rest Will Flow”, “Where We Would Be”, the 1st half of “Last Chance to Evacuate Planet Earth Before it is Recycled” & “Feel So Low” – Stupid Dream (#5)
  • “Four Chords That Made a Million” & the 2nd half of “Last Chance to Evacuate Planet Earth Before it is Recycled” – Up The Downstair (#2), Signify (#4)
  • “Shesmovedon” – In Absentia (#7), Deadwing (#8)
  • “Hatesong” & “Russia On Ice” – Signify (#4), In Absentia (#7)

#7: “In Absentia”

Summary: While continuing the song-based direction from the previous two albums, In Absentia is also the first album in the discography to feature doses of heavy metallic guitar (a result of Steven Wilson producing several albums for the metal band Opeth).

Release: September 2002

lF31w42
The artwork created for In Absentia by Lasse Hoile

If this was your first choice, you’re likely here because you like heavy guitars and tight, focused arrangements!

“Sonically gorgeous and deceivingly complex, In Absentia has the most immediate appeal of anything Wilson has released under this moniker up to this point… Porcupine Tree has grown into a fully realized pop group without cutting any of the elements that also make them an important force in the neo-prog movement.” – AllMusic

g

Links:

Now that you’ve listened to it, what songs on the album did you like the most?

  • “Blackest Eyes” & “Wedding Nails” – Deadwing (#8)
  • “Trains”, “Lips of Ashes”, “The Sound of Muzak”, “Prodigal”, “Heartattack in a Layby” & “Collapse The Light Into Earth” – Stupid Dream (#5), Lightbulb Sun (#6)
  • “Gravity Eyelids” & “.3” – The Sky Moves Sideways (#3), Signify (#4), Fear of a Blank Planet (#9)
  • “The Creator Has a Mastertape” & “Strip the Soul” – Fear of a Blank Planet (#9), The Incident (#10)

#8: “Deadwing”

Summary: Deadwing sees the band further hone the song-based style they had begun to develop since Stupid Dream and naturally fuse the newly-found metal element into their “sound”.

Release: March 2005

yYBlIzQ
The artwork created for Deadwing by Lasse Hoile

g

“It’s both highly accessible and moderately challenging, technically proficient but also economical in its instrumentation, as well as soft and delicate while also tending to be crushingly heavy at moments… between the varied songwriting and consistently well-executed instrumental work, it stands as one of Porcupine Tree’s finest hours.” – Sputnik Music

t

Links:

 

Now that you’ve listened to it, what songs on the album did you like the most?

  • “Deadwing”, “Shallow” & “Open Car” – In Absentia (#7), The Incident (#10)
  • “Lazarus”, “Halo”, “Mellotron Scratch” & “Start of Something Beautiful” – Stupid Dream (#5), Lightbulb Sun (#6)
  • “Arriving Somewhere But Not Here” & “Glass Arm Shattering” – The Sky Moves Sideways (#3), Signify (#4)

#9: “Fear of a Blank Planet”

Summary: 

Release:

2007_FOABP
The artwork created for Fear of a Blank Planet by Lasse Hoile

g

links

Now that you’ve listened to it, what songs on the album did you like the most?

  • “Fear of a Blank Planet” – Deadwing (#8)
  • “My Ashes” & “Sentimental” – Stupid Dream (#5), Lightbulb Sun (#6)
  • “Anesthetize” – The Sky Moves Sideways (#3), The Incident (#10)
  • “Way Out of Here” – In Absentia (#7)
  • “Sleep Together” – Up The Downstair (#2), Signify (#4), Deadwing (#8)

#10: “The Incident”

Summary: Combining the metallic edge of In Absentia and Deadwing and the song-based material of Stupid Dream and Lightbulb Sun, The Incident shows off everything that makes Porcupine Tree, well, Porcupine Tree.

Release: September 2010

2009_The_Incident
The artwork created for The Incident by Lasse Hoile

g

Links:

Now that you’ve listened to it, what songs on the album did you like the most?

  • “The Blind House” & “Circle of Manias” – In Absentia (#7), Deadwing (#8)
  • “Great Expectations”, “Kneel and Disconnect”, “Drawing the Line”, “Your Unpleasant Family”, “Time Flies”, “The Seance”, “I Drive the Hearse” & “Remember Me Lover” – Stupid Dream (#5), Lightbulb Sun (#6)
  • “The Incident”, “Octane Twisted” & “Bonnie the Cat” – Signify (#4), In Absentia (#7), Fear of a Blank Planet (#9)
  • “Way Out of Here” – In Absentia (#7)
  • “Sleep Together” – Up The Downstair (#2), Signify (#4), Deadwing (#8)

Additional Releases

Over the years, Steven Wilson has delegated some of his greatest tracks to b-side status, just because they didn’t “fit in”. As a result, there are many more releases outside of the main 10 studio albums that are just as strong and interesting!

SW: “I think it’s very interesting to draw analogies with cinema. I’ve heard directors talking about movies they’ve made, and they say, ‘This scene we shot was my favorite scene in the movie, but when we came to edit the movie, it just didn’t fit, so we had to take it out.’ I think that’s the case sometimes with music tracks–you can be really proud of them, but sometimes they break the momentum of an album.”

Obviously, there’s lots more Porcupine Tree to digest, including many fantastic live albums, so I’m going to break down all of the major additional releases in a similar, although more streamlined fashion to the studio material. Just scroll through the list of releases and see if they appeal to you! They are organized in what I called “packages”, releases that are somehow tied together, whether it be live albums featuring certain tracks or were just released in the same time period. Each package will “round” out an era of the band you have listened to with material that I consider to be essential. I have organized them from most accessible to least accessible. Of course, you can still listen in any order you wish.

Package #1 (2001–2005):

Recordings

Summary: A collection of songs left off Stupid Dream and Lightbulb Sun, Recordings is anything but a hastily thrown together pool of outtakes. Some of the greatest songs Steven Wilson has ever written are in this compilation and, in my opinion, this is just as essential as the studio albums.

Release: May 2001

Untitled design (7)

 

 

 

 

Futile

Summary: This download only EP contains additional material from the In Absentia sessions, including favourites from the band.

Release: July 2003

Untitled design (10)
The artwork created for Futile by Lasse Hoile

g

Lazarus

Summary: A single taken from Deadwing, Lazarus features two other incredible tracks that were left off the album but frequently played live.

Release: March 2005

Untitled design (9)

 

 

Arriving Somewhere…

Summary: A powerful and excellent sounding live performance that sees the band playing material mostly from Deadwing and In Absentia, but also with some choice cuts from Stupid Dream, Lightbulb Sun and Recordings.

Release: August 2006 (recorded October 12th–13th 2005)

Untitled design (5)

 

If you want more material like this, check out Rockpalast. I have not included it in this package because I consider Arriving Somewhere… to have both a better tracklist and performance while also sounding better than Rockpalast. That said, Rockpalast is still excellent in its own right although Arriving Somewhere… covers similar ground.

 

Warszawa

Summary: The last recording to feature original drummer Chris Maitland, Warszawa is an intimate live recording that captures the band playing the bulk of material found on Stupid Dream and Lightbulb Sun.

Release: February 2004 (recorded April 6th 2001)

Warzawa Snapper Grid

 

I placed Warszawa last in this package because I believe you should watch Arriving Somewhere… first as it covers more material.

 

 

Package #2 (2007–2012):

Nil Recurring

Summary: Featuring two tracks recorded during the Fear of a Blank Planet sessions and two recorded right after, Nil Recurring is an explosive release that may have been missed by many fans.

Release: September 2007

2007_Nil_Recurring_2

 

Anesthetize

Summary: A phenomenal live album/film that captures the band at their most powerful, playing the entirety of Fear of a Blank Planet and other selections from the likes of Nil Recurring, In Absentia and Signify.

Release: May 2010 (recorded October 15th–16th 2008)

Untitled design (4)

atlanta, but no essential

Untitled design (19)

 

We Lost The Skyline

Summary: An intimate acoustic set with Steven Wilson and John Wesley, We Lost The Skyline is a fun listen through the Porcupine Tree catalogue, featuring many rare tracks not usually played live.

Release: February 2008 (recorded October 4th 2007)

Untitled design (3)

 

Octane Twisted

Summary: The last ever Porcupine Tree release, Octane Twisted is a live album that captures both the entirety of the 55-minute The Incident title piece and fan-favourites such as “Dislocated Day”, the full-length version of “Even Less” and “Stars Die”.

Release: November 2012 (recorded April 30th 2010 and October 14th 2010)

2010_Octane_Twisted

 

Package #3 (1994–1998):

Transmission IV: Moonloop

Summary: A mind-bendingly funky improvisation that clocks in at over 40 minutes, Transmission IV: Moonloop was later edited for release on The Sky Moves Sideways.

Release: 

 

Untitled design (11)

Stars Die: The Delerium Years 1991–1997 (Disc 2)

Summary: 

Release: March 2002

107 Booklet.indd

SW: Stars Die is an overview of the Delerium years 1990-97 and represents the best material from that era. It’s kind of a beginners guide to the many new fans who are discovering PT with the more recent material.

Coma Divine

Summary: A blistering live album that captures three nights in Rome, Coma Divine is a testament to just how great the band are on stage. Featuring many early tracks interpreted by the whole band, Coma Divine is great to ease someone into the Porcupine Tree back catalogue.

Release: October 1997 (recorded March 25th–27th 1997)

Untitled design (6)

 

Metanoia

Summary: A collection of spacey improvisations recorded in 1995 and 1996, Metanoia is a fun release that shows off the chemistry between all four members.

Release: December 1998

Untitled design (8)

 

Insignificance

Summary: A collection of demos and unfinished outtakes from the Signify sessions, Insignificance is a fun listen that provides a look into how Steven Wilson prepares his songs for the band.

Release: March 1997

pic

g

Package #4 (1990–1994):

Stars Die: The Delerium Years 1991–1997 (Disc 1)

Summary:

Release: March 2002

107 Booklet.indd

 

Staircase Infinities

Summary:

Release: December 1994

Untitled design (2)

also worth finding an old mix of utd

Voyage 34: The Complete Trip

Summary:

Release:

Untitled design (14)

g

Yellow Hedgerow Dreamscape

Summary: 

Release: 

 

Untitled design (15)

g

Rarities

One of the best things about Porcupine Tree is that their outtakes and non-album tracks are just as strong (and sometimes even stronger than) the songs on the studio albums. There’s always something to discover in the Porcupine Tree catalogue, and it’s a ton of fun to wander through. For this reason, I have not got into as much detail as before because I believe it is important each fan find their own rarities and b-sides. However, I have included some general information below.

Release History

 

This list only contains major releases such as studio albums, live albums, EPs and compilations. For a more detailed look at Porcupine Tree’s discography, check out the Discography: Porcupine Tree page.

The Super Simple Guide to Porcupine Tree

Listen to In Absentia and Stupid Dream. Did you like the heavy stuff like “Blackest Eyes” and “Slave Called Shiver”? Listen to Deadwing, Signify, Fear of a Blank Planet, Nil Recurring and The Incident. Liked the softer and catchier stuff like “Trains” and “Pure Narcotic”? Listen to Lightbulb Sun and Recordings. The albums you’ve just checked out cover the time period from 1996–2010, when Porcupine Tree was a completely band-oriented project (before this time, Porcupine Tree was a solo vehicle for Steven Wilson).

Okay, now it’s time to delve into the more psychedelic back catalogue. First, listen to Stars Die: The Delerium Years 1991–1997 and Coma Divine. The former is a great compilation that will ease you into the early years, while the latter is a phenomenal live album that features many early tracks interpreted by the whole band. Now that you’re all warmed up, check out The Sky Moves Sideways, Up The Downstair, Staircase Infinities and On The Sunday of Life… (in that order).

Congratulations, you’ve now listened to the many different sides of Porcupine Tree!

Written by Quinn Downton